After everything I wrote yesterday I figured I should actually post my opinion on what I called "The Hillsong Question"! Not sure if that will detract from my anti-bashing stance yesterday but here goes.
Firstly I think Hillsong is genuine in what they say. I don't believe in any way that they are trying to trick people into anything whether that be giving them money, attending their church or even Christianity.
Also, one thing that got me respecting them was that they stated (numerous times) that they are not an example church to be copied. They do not want 100s of mini-Hillsongs springing up around Australia (and the world). They advocate creating a church that works for the particular congregation. Just because a church is successful here does not mean it will be everywhere. I know that churches still copy the Hillsong model but I like the fact that the leadership of Hillsong isn't saying "we have all the answers, come and be like us!"
Having said that, their 'prosperity teaching' worries me. Being prosperous in itself is not a bad thing but I'm not too sure about being blessed by God or loved by God because you have given money to Him (His church). I could be wrong and getting my messages mixed but I got the impression on some occasions at Hillsong conference. I think, no I know, that God loves us unconditionally and while I believe that giving money to the church/a charity pleases Him and continues His work, I don't think that makes Him love us more. (And consequently not giving doesn't make him love us less.) To me, God blesses us because he loves us, not because we give 10%, 20% or 50% of our pay to the church.
I love a lot of their music, it's easy to sing, easy to learn and it has really helped to bring church music up to date and more accessible for other. However sometimes I worry about the feeling of the services and 'worship' in them. I found myself crying for absolutely no reason during the 'worship.' To me, it felt like I was being emotionally led and I wasn't sure why. It was
too emotional and I couldn't pin down the reason. If that had been a once off feeling then I think I wouldn't have been so worried/cynical but it was at every service and I found that it was a bit much.
I think in that emotion-charged environment we can sing words and not realize what we're singing and consequently not mean what we're singing. Maybe that's not a big deal for a lot of people but it is for me. I believe God takes us at our word and if I sing (or talk) about wanting to sacrifice myself for him (for example) then he can and will take me up on that. Now if I sing that without meaning it and knowing what I'm saying ... well, then I'm in trouble! :-) And does it make it fake if I don't know what I'm saying? I want to be honest and real with my Heavenly Father and therefore if I don't agree with something I'm singing in a song, then I don't' want to sing it to him. You could argue that I sing pop songs about inconsequential things that I don't necessarily agree with and you'd be right. But the difference there is that it's not part of a church service/"worship" time that I'm committing to God. (I don't like using the term 'worship' for the service because I believe that 'worship' is everything we do ... but that's for another post, another time.)
Also with the worship I experienced at Hillsong conference. For me, it's kinda like losing control. Yes, that can be a good thing but like I said, I don't agree with not knowing why I'm happy/sad/crying/laughing etc. in a worship service. You could argue that I'm just a control freak and maybe you're right, but that's how I feel!
Basically I think Hillsong does some great things and that people who attend the conferences/church/college or whatever, should go with a discerning mind and pray about it, asking God to show them what they need to see and to help them sort the good from the bad.
Whew! There's a bit there. Honestly I don't' think I've said all that I want to say and how I want to say it but that's a start. I hope I have refrained from bitching and "Hillsong-bashing" because otherwise, what kind of a hypocrite am I?!
If anyone wants to comment about this topic which can get quite passionate, please keep it nice! This is just my opinion, it's not right or wrong it just my opinion. I might be mistaken about some of the facts and assumptions I'm making but an opinion in itself is personal and not a fact, so don't degenerate to name calling and I'll do the same for you. Thanks ;-)